Skip to main content

NFL Draft grades don't pass this test

My beef with the NFL Draft doesn't end with the hours of television time it eats up.

It continues right through to the grading of teams after the draft.

This is another exercise in futility.

The problem is the preconception of players by those handing out grades.

The gurus who grade the teams for their performance, or lack thereof, already are locked into a belief of where a player should or should not be drafted.

So let's say Draft Guru A has Football Star B rated really high on his draft board.

For some reason, the NFL teams selecting players keep passing on Football Star B. When a team finally gets around to drafting our broken-hearted player in the third round, Draft Guru A will rave about what a steal that selection was.


Maybe Draft Guru A doesn't want to look so bad. Maybe it's a way to cover his behind.

By the time everyone figures out Football Star B doesn't have the talent to be a starter in the NFL, we'll have forgotten about Draft Guru A's assessment.

So while you're going through the post-draft analysis of your favorite team, just keep that in mind.

We'll know the real answers in the fall.


  1. The only way to judge a draft is to wait three years. How did those players from 2009 perform over the first three years of their contracts? That gives the later picks time to learn the NFL and time to succeed, suck or muddle along.

  2. Yeah, we finally know about that 2006 Steelers draft. Some guy named Santonio Holmes kinda worked out, didn't he?


Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Baseball and poker similar in how action unfolds

The game of poker has received a bad rap for years for being too boring. Due to longperiods of inactivity in a game, players tend to tune out of the game. The funny thing
is, Baseball is also one that many of these same people happen to like even though
sometimes it also has has similar long periods of inactivity, even if those long periods are
not shown on TV.

In big poker tournaments, such as the highlights we see in the World Series of Poker, has
skewed the reality of how long of a process that the game can really be. Sometimes even
in baseball, during the World Series there are long period of innings where there isn’t
much going on, like in poker except one person raising and others folding.

That can change quickly and sometimes just as dramatically as a big solo shot homer. A
player can make a raise, followed by a three-bet from another player. The original raiser
then moves all-in and gets called. Now, all the people watching the event are on their
feet cheering and screaming fo…

So much for Byron the great backup

I never understood the Steelers' fascination with their backup quarterbacks.

They've had either Charlie Batch and Byron Leftwich for what seems like ages now.

And when the Steelers really needed a backup, Leftwich couldn't deliver.

Leftwich rambled 31 yards for a touchdown Sunday against the Ravens, but other than that burst, the Steelers couldn't do anything on offense in a 13-10 loss that puts them in a bad position in the AFC North.

Leftwich, with his long delivery, looks better suited for the Pirates' bullpen than behind center.

He went 18-for-39 passing for 201 yards, but couldn't help a Steelers' offense that looks lost right now.

The Ravens came into the game with a weak defense. The thought was Leftwich could manage the game, the Steelers could find a running back to rely on and they'd escape with a win.

It didn't work out that way.

And it looks like we could see Batch at QB this week -- or someone else.

The Steelers are worried about Leftw…